• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant: Authentic Italian Flavor in Sparrow Bush, NY

Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant, located at 32 Main St, Sparrow Bush, NY, is a culinary gem that blends genuine Italian flavors with a welcoming atmosphere. Renowned for their exceptional pizzas and pastas, this eatery has garnered a loyal following thanks to their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Guests rave about signature dishes like the Charlie's Special and Grandma's Pie, while also appreciating the family-like service. Catering options shine, with delightful treats from chicken parmesan to delectable desserts like cannolis. Mamma Grace is where comforting food meets heartfelt hospitality, making every visit feel like a family gathering.

Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 32 Main St, Sparrow Bush, NY 12780, United States
  • Phone +1 845-672-4444
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

kira Fisher
5

What can I say about this place excellent food great service and they treat you like family and if you are feeling like something and it’s not on their menu they will take a shot at making it for you from their pizza to their pasta it’s all delicious Thank you for catering our wedding.

Alex Kadansky
5

UPDATE: July 7th, 2022 This place can hold it's own against any pizza joint in Brooklyn...The Charlie's special with broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella and garlic is delicious, and the Grandma's Pie with that pesto drizzle and added pepperoni was just amazing. The Mamma Grace special, the garlic knots and the rice ball parm were just as finger licking good. This place is a gem in such a beautiful part of New York that delivers, thanx again Mamma Grace for taking care of us. Being new to Glen Spey, we were looking for a taste of home, Brooklyn pizza, and we just found it at Mamma Grace. From the Sicilian with chicken and broccoli, to the fried calamari, to the eggplant roll and the garlic knots, everything tasted fresh and delicious. Can't wait to taste the rest of their huge menu...Thanx Mamma

Charlotte Van Horn
5

Momma Grace catered for us today and it was fabulous. Chicken park, chicken Frances’s, sausage and peppers. Cannolis, cheesecake and an absolutely fabulous rainbow cake!

Checkered Demon
3

Wife and I ordered chicken parm sandwiches and pepperoni pinwheels. The chicken was dry and pinwheels were overcooked. Sauce seems to be missing something also. Though their pasta dinners are good. Especially seafood diavolo

Rea
3

I picked up a large pie for my friend, she was having her Grandkiddies over. I just dropped it off. She called me & said the pie was dry & tasteless & the slices cut so uneven. Looking at the pic I would say she was definitely correct. Isn't there a guide that can be used to slice up a pie? I asked her to save a slice so I can taste it, it really does look dry. Anyway, 1st impression, not a good one. Maybe next time?

Leeta Law
5

Wonderful place! Excellent customer service. Definitely family run. The food was hot and delicious. We got a pepperoni pizza and a gyro on a pita. Pizza had a delicious dough and a great sauce. Gyro had a yummy sauce and a good amount of tomatoes, lettuce and meat. There are about 4-5 tables inside if you want to eat in. Everything seems clean too. Would totally recommend!

jeremiahryan
3

I waited a while to give an honest review, The owner and husband are nice, the stars they lose for atmosphere will Likely go up once they finish their renovations and fix parking, as it is now there are only 2 tables and 2 parking spots. This leaves a mad dash when they are busy. I tried the plain slice and if you like a more sweet and sugary sauce this is the place. I was told that their plain isn’t their best and that they specialize in Sicilian grandma pies. I’ll be sure to check that out next time, as of now, as a dine in restaurant for a family of 5, It’s best to order delivery from here. And avoid the plain if you like savory thin and crispy slices. The grandmas pie is the 3 stars this review is getting, it was worth the return for the single slice. They should call it Mama Graces Grandma Pies and Pizza. Would sell their strengths more!

Location

  • Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant
    Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant
    32 Main St, Sparrow Bush, NY 12780, United States Hotline: +1 845-672-4444

Welcome to Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant, a delightful eatery nestled in the heart of Sparrow Bush, New York. With its address at 32 Main St, Sparrow Bush, NY 12780, and a friendly voice at +1 845-672-4444, Mamma Grace has quickly established itself as a cherished dining destination.

This charming pizzeria captures the essence of family dining, creating an inviting atmosphere where every patron feels like part of the Mamma Grace family. Customers rave about the exceptional food and outstanding service, which often goes above and beyond to cater to individual tastes—if you have a craving that isn’t on the menu, the staff is more than willing to whip it up just for you.

Among the notable highlights that keep customers coming back for more are their mouthwatering specialty pizzas. A must-try is the Charlie's Special, featuring sautéed broccoli rabe, savory sausage, fresh mozzarella, and garlic—a combination that has garnered rave reviews. Another standout is the Grandma's Pie, drizzled with pesto and pepperoni, offering a perfect balance of flavors that will leave your taste buds singing. Guests have compared Mamma Grace’s pies to those from Brooklyn, a testament to the authenticity and quality of their offerings.

But Mamma Grace is not just about pizza. Their pasta dishes, like the Seafood Diavolo, have received commendation for freshness and taste. Chicken Parmesan and Chicken Francese were particularly notable during a recent catering event, alongside decadent desserts like cannolis and a stunning rainbow cake that stole the show.

While there is no establishment without its critics, with some diners raising points about dryness in certain dishes, the overwhelming consensus is that Mamma Grace delivers a culinary experience that’s simply too good to overlook. Whether you are enjoying a casual meal or arranging for a special event, Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant promises a feast that reflects both tradition and innovation.

In a world filled with dining options, Mamma Grace stands as a gem—perfectly situated in a picturesque part of New York, offering food that is not just delicious but also crafted with personal touch. It’s more than a meal; it’s a true taste of home. So why not stop by and discover the delightful offerings at Mamma Grace? Your taste buds will thank you.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards